You are here: Manchester Confidential › Food & Drink › Modern European.

Well, the debate rages on. Is fine dining dead in Manchester? For Gordo, the answer is as difficult to grasp as Southern Cemetery mist, but a little less interesting. Gordo has sat in front of a computer screen for fifty minutes and having written 1200 words he finds he has deleted 1170 of them. With a story deadline looming, he is, unusually, stuck. He wants to change the subject. But since this is a review of The River Restaurant at The Lowry, which is capable of scoring at the very high end of the region’s restaurants, he feels he must put some kind of stake in the ground. Or steak on a plate.
Fine dining. Hmm. The Mirabelle, Mayfair. 1979. Gordo, aged 23, took his Uncle, Alfie Alexander, and a couple of very aristocratic ladies for dinner. White cloths, armchairs at the table, silver service. Lobster for four people, with a choice of sauce antiboise, Andalous, tartare or vincent.
Gordo’s guest, Cat, was motoring through a ceviche of scallop (£12.50): a dish fit for Marie Antoinette on a hot day at Versailles
A Chateau Briand to die for, the ladies on huge Dover soles. They slouched over their plates even after they had been boned by an immaculate waiter in a white tie. The mâitre d’ preparing the crêpes suzette by the table. A wine waiter so in command that he helped himself to a small glass of each bottle ordered by Gordo without asking, including a 1953 Chateau Mouton Rothschild and a 1942 Chateau d’Yquem, which had a stamp across the label declaring it to be ‘Reserved for the Wehrmarcht’.
It was the custom, how else could he tell the next client how the wine was drinking? A lady who lighted your big fat Monte Cristo Number 2 cigar by dabbing it into a flame on the end of a twelve inch, very thick match for two, for maybe three minutes and handing it to you perfectly lit.
The bill? £829. For four. Twenty seven years ago.
Now that, dear readers, is, was, fine dining. Yes we don’t have it any more in Manchester. Gordo isn’t too sure we ever did. Even at the French. So let’s drop the bloody subject and have a look at a high-end dining experience.
The River Restaurant at The Lowry.
Gordo likes the setting, for some it’s impersonal. It sure is quality, whatever tickles your architectural fancy. With a view down a river that was once the most polluted in Europe, now a habitat for swans, this is one of the best locations in Manchester. Ok, Salford. The staff are well known to Gordo, Marc Whitley the manager a remarkable man, in the towns top three with a brigade behind him who know their stuff and don’t mess about. A mistake pouring the red wine was instantly forgiven.
Two starters. First, seared foie gras, pineapple carpaccio and spiced port syrup (£12.50). Top three starters in the last year or so this, a tad behind Ramsey’s when Gordo was last at Claridges, but way above anything the North West has to show so far. Pretty thick slice, pan fried deftly so we have a caramelised outside, made crunchy with a little sea salt, the pineapple cutting the hyper rich interior whilst the port sauce danced around the two main ingredients giving them a little tickle just in the right places. Grand stuff. Gordo’s guest, Cat, was motoring through a ceviche of scallop with apple, watermelon and cider dressing (£12.50) which was a dish fit for Marie Antoinette on a hot day at Versailles. Girls, you will love it. Sorry to be sexist but it really was the most delightfully feminine of dishes.
Before this we were treated, by the way, to cold cucumber soup which arrived with a sliver of toasted bread, two steps up from melba toast and tastier, with smoked salmon, sour cream and caviar. Next time Gordo has this he will try a very cold, very good vodka with it.
Mains were rack of salt marsh lamb, pine nut raisin crust and minted pea puree (£22.50) for Gordo and Roast pork cutlet, celeriac and apple puree with a cider jus (£18.50) for Cat. Eyck Zimmer, the fantastic Ossi (East German) chef obsesses with ingredients. It shows with the meats, they are of such quality they sing: cooked on the underdone side, the pork is succulent and tastes lovely and piggy, chestnuts and acorns showing through. Gordo has been off lamb this year but Eyck’s salt marsh has changed his mind. Maybe time for a rack off the shelves in M&S. Both plates have well chosen accompaniments with them, the pea puree for the lamb standing up off the plate and slapping Gordo across his chubby cheeks. Have a look at the photos, they speak for themselves.
Why then Marc, do your staff wonder if ‘Sir’ would like any sides with these? Are Eyck’s dishes delivered short of the necessary bits and pieces? Gordo thinks not, as well as thinking that a further £3.50 for sautéed spinach or half a potato formed into (very good mind) fat chips is a tad dear. Reader, do not waste your money, these are well balanced and definitely not mean platefuls. Let’s start a protest at ‘sides’ by leaving them alone.
Puddings don’t let the side down, Cat’s retro Manchester tart was an improvement on Grosvenor Road primary in Salford. The Earl Grey scented crème brûlée with Eccles cakes was top of the class, the Earl Grey foam on top of the brûlée wasn’t just for show. The Eccles cakes might be superfluous and not quite juicy enough. Puddings are all priced at £7.50.
Petits four were eaten with coffee, Gordo can’t remember how much these were.
This is as high end dining, as far from the ‘cook by numbers’ of the high street medium range restaurants as you can get. The silver service is gone along with white ties on waiters and cooking at the table, but let Gordo tell you dear reader, this meal was every bit as enjoyable as The Mirabelle nearly thirty years ago, in fact the ingredients were probably better.
Just one thing: turn those lights down a bit Marc, the ladies like it soft.
| Rating: | 18.75/20 (three visits) |
| Breakdown: | 9.25/10 Food 4.75/5 Service 4.5/5 Ambience |
| Address: | The River Restaurant Lowry Hotel Dearman’s Place Off Chapel Street City www.thelowryhotel.com 0161 827 4000 |
Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great videos, food reviews, news, deals and savings.
13 comments so far, continue the conversation, write a comment.
Anonymous, is that you Mr. Pilling? Quite right George, I got very drunk and can't remember the price....
Gordo - I will gladly go with you to our City's catering establishments and taste/drink their house wines to find out who serves the best, but most importandly check the prices - yes, value for money.
Ray, pop to Sam's Chop House and have a look at their new wine list, you will find there some very good, interesting, cross section selection of wines with a varied choice across all price levels and styles. No doubt you know well enough the style of food Sam serves, and yes, there are a lot of wines that match this traditional English kitchen. I also must point out to the selection of wines by the glass and extensive bin end list.
I dont nw what all the fuss is about,i just like to go to fancy places drink expensive wines and generally get inebriated ,once in a fine state I like to insult the staff and fellow diners then leave a large tip!
I dined at The River Room last night and had probably the most enjoyable meal I have ever had in Manchester. The pressed chicken terrine was not a patch on that Ian Morgan used to do at Establishment - but everything else was fantastic and the service was efficient and friendly.
Thanks for the update on Sam's list. I do like their 1978 Monte Real - almost a bargain at £45. However, I have hitherto found Sam's markups to be a tad on the steep side with no roll-off as prices increase (thereby doing little to encourage "trading up"). Given that I have had the odd glass with George WJB, I'm up for trying out house wines too!Gordo - good to hear that Dujac wines are on the list. Village wines, I presume? Can't see a Grand Cru for only £70....Not long back from Tate Britain where a 37.5cl Margaux 89 was only £155! Even better, a Billecart Cuvée NF 97 was £62. Now THAT's a bargain.Moet - I take your point re ageing. Mind you, it would have to improve (it's very poor on release). Now if you want to bring your aged Moet, I'd be happy to put it up against, say, a Vilmart at a similar price. Less marketing budget = better wine!
Steve, you need to take me with you as your consultant -)
I haven't, as it happens, but i have always found the bar snacks and service to be possibly the best of all the theatres in the area. I will try and do a full review in the next couple of months
Thanks Gordo for this review, you have helped me partly solve where to go whilst the French is closed for their holiday during part of August.Is it any use in me mentioning your name ? and are you going to the Pomery night at the Room ? if so see you there.
Ever done a review of the restaurant in The Lowry Theatre at Salford Quays? I'd be very interested in seeing how it fares.
Ray, you are of course absolutely correct. I drank a remarkable Chateau du Seuil, from Cerons with the fois gras Cerons is just on the border of Sauterns in Bordeaux and is a sweet white, I have never had it before, slightly less sweet than, say, a Rieussec but a lot less money. It's been well written about in Decanter magazine. I then had an italian red, a Barbera d'Alba, quite like these nowadays, this one at £50 - ish. The remarkable thing then was the house red, having finished the Italian bottle I only fancied a glass. A Merlot, I liked it better than the d'alba (Bricca San Biagio)so I have decided that I am on a mission to see who does the best house wines now. Anyone up for that? Cat's white was a Californian chardonnay, which was the house wine again and although I haven't drunk new world chardonnay for a while, it got very boring, this one restored my faith, fantastic. The list overall I have found to be outstanding, priced from £18 or so up to stupidly priced, as mentioned, champagnes. Domain Dujac Burgundies on the list, tad dear at £70, will blow your underpants off. Gordo's tip on champagne by the way, Buy half a dozen ordinary Moet's, put them under the kitchen sink for a year, then try 'em. They drink like a wine at three times the price. Your comments are always appreciated.
Ray, you are a man after my own heart. What's the answer, Gordo?
Glad the meal was just as enjoyable, but what was the wine list like? Was there a varied choice across all price points and styles, or was it the same dreary bling champagnes and not much else? I'm interested, as the selection and availability of good wines with a top end meal can be almost as important as the food, and certainly more important than the décor.